Thursday, February 23, 2006

U.S. Detainees' Deaths Go Unaccounted

While a rights group says many go unpunished, Pentagon disagrees.
By Drew Brown, Inquirer Washington Bureau
Philadelphia Inquirer
February 23, 2006

WASHINGTON - Ninety-eight detainees in Iraq and Afghanistan have died in U.S. custody since August 2002, and 34 of them were suspected or confirmed homicides, a human-rights group reported yesterday.

Only 12 cases have resulted in punishment of any kind, New York-based Human Rights First said in its report.

Taken together, the deaths reflect a pattern of systematic and widespread abuse by U.S. troops, CIA operatives, and civilian contractors caused by vague policies governing interrogation procedures and a lax command atmosphere in which abuses are either encouraged or ignored, the group charged.

"People are dying in U.S. custody, and no one is being held to account," said Deborah Pearlstein, U.S. law and security program director at Human Rights First.

In close to half of the 98 cases that Human Rights First examined, the official cause of death remained undetermined or unannounced, the group said. At least eight of the homicides resulted from torture, the group concluded. The 128-page report was based on official Army documents, published accounts and interviews.

The Pentagon acknowledged that deaths in U.S. custody have occurred, but a spokesman rejected the report's findings.

"We fully investigate every detainee death no matter what the circumstances are to ensure that every aspect of detainee operations has been humane," Lt. Col. Mark Ballesteros said. "The Department of Defense's policy has always been to treat detainees in our custody humanely. To state that the department has not held people accountable in cases of detainee mistreatment is not accurate."

Ballesteros said that the U.S. military had investigated more than 600 allegations of detainee abuse. Approximately 250 servicemen and servicewomen have been held accountable for their actions, he said.

"People have been sent to jail for detainee mistreatment," he said.

One of 20 questionable deaths profiled in the report is that of Dilar Dababa, 45, an Iraqi who died of a blow to the head during an interrogation at a U.S. detention camp in Iraq in June 2003, according to a military autopsy report.

His body was covered with at least 22 bruises and 50 abrasions, most on his head and neck. He suffered bleeding in the brain and a fractured rib. Military investigators reported a year later that they were looking into Dababa's death, but no charges had been filed.

In the 34 deaths that the U.S. military classified as suspected or confirmed homicides, investigators recommended criminal charges in fewer than two-thirds, the report said. The most severe sentence handed down in any of the homicide cases was 25 years in jail, said Hani Shamsi, the primary author of the report.

Chief Warrant Officer Lewis Welshofer, who was convicted last month of negligent homicide after stuffing a former Iraqi general headfirst into a sleeping bag and suffocating him during a November 2003 interrogation, was given a reprimand, fined $6,000, and restricted in his movements for 60 days.

Retired Army Brig. Gen. David R. Irvine said that U.S. military officers were ultimately responsible for the actions of the soldiers under their command but that almost none had been held accountable.

"Soldiers became torturers because their chain of command chose to look the other way," he said.

Only one high-ranking officer, former Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinski, has been disciplined for prisoner abuse by those under her command, at Abu Ghraib. She was reprimanded and demoted to colonel.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home